The Atlantic Ocean's width varies enormously depending on latitude—so much so that a single number is misleading. From the narrow Strait of Gibraltar to the vast expanse between Brazil and West Africa, the Atlantic's breadth tells a story of plate tectonics and continental drift.
The Atlantic is an ocean basin formed by the separation of the North American, South American, Eurasian, and African plates. The Mid-Atlantic Ridge runs down its center, where new crust forms and pushes the continents apart at 2–4 cm/year. The basin's hourglass shape—narrow at the equator, widening toward the tropics, narrowing again toward the Arctic—reflects the geometry of the separating continental margins.
The Pacific Ocean averages ~10,000 miles wide at the equator—more than double the Atlantic's maximum. The Indian Ocean spans ~4,000 miles at its widest. The Atlantic's relative narrowness is why it was the first ocean crossed regularly by steamships and telegraph cables, shaping modern globalization.
Whether you're measuring for navigation, cable laying, or climate modeling, always specify the latitude. The Atlantic's width is a function of where you ask the question.