The Caribbean Sea is unequivocally part of the Atlantic Ocean—a marginal sea bounded by the Americas, not a Pacific feature.
Water enters via: North Equatorial Current → Caribbean Current → Yucatán Current → Loop Current → Florida Current → Gulf Stream. The Caribbean is the Gulf Stream's birthplace.
Isthmus of Panama (formed ~3 Ma) separates Caribbean (Atlantic) from Pacific. Before closure: single tropical ocean. After: Pacific cooler, saltier; Caribbean warmer, less saline. Panama Canal (1914) reconnects artificially (locks, not open flow).
Columbus (1492), Spanish treasure fleets, piracy, plantation slavery, Monroe Doctrine, WWII U-boats, Cuban Missile Crisis, modern tourism (30M+ visitors/yr), drug transit, hurricane genesis.
The Caribbean is Atlantic through and through—its warm waters fuel the current that warms Europe.