Sultanahmet is in Europe. The historic peninsula that cradles Hagia Sophia, the Blue Mosque, Topkapı Palace, and the Basilica Cistern sits on the European shore of the Bosphorus Strait, bordered by the Golden Horn to the north and the Sea of Marmara to the south.
This peninsula was Constantinople—capital of Eastern Rome, then Ottoman Empire. Its European location anchored its role as the gateway between continents, the terminus of the Silk Road, and the stage for 1,600 years of imperial history.
Üsküdar, Kadıköy, Beykoz, Çengelköy — residential, commercial, quieter, with ferries linking to Eminönü (5 min), Karaköy (10 min), Beşiktaş (15 min) on the European side.
So when you stand in Sultanahmet Square facing the Blue Mosque, you're standing in Europe—with Asia a short ferry ride away.