Here are some reasons why peninsulares held such a high status:
Power and authority: Peninsulares were directly appointed by Spanish Crown, they represented the authority and power of the Spanish Empire in the colony.
Education: Peninsulares generally received higher education in Spain and were considered more educated and intellectual than other social groups in Mexico City.
Economic dominance: Many peninsulares held key economic positions and controlled trade, commerce, and large estates in the colony. They were wealthy and influential, which solidified their social standing.
Legal and political advantages: Peninsulares had access to education and legal protection that were not readily available to other social groups. They held significant political and legal privileges.
Close cultural ties to Spain: Peninsulares maintained strong cultural ties to Spain and were often seen as the true representatives of Spanish values and traditions.
Social discrimination: Discrimination against other social groups, such as criollos (Spaniards born in the colony), mestizos (mixed Spanish and indigenous heritage), and indigenous people, helped maintain the dominance of peninsulares.
While peninsulares occupied the top of the social hierarchy, other groups like criollos, mestizos, and indigenous peoples had varying degrees of social status, rights, and opportunities based on their racial background, social origin, and economic position. Nonetheless, the hierarchy and privilege of peninsulares were central to colonial society in Mexico City.