Home
# Travel >> Destinations >> United Kingdom

Where to Sell a 1 oz Silver American Eagle in New York City

Selling a **1 oz American Silver Eagle** (ASE) in NYC: aim for **spot price + small premium** (typically $1–$3 over spot for generic; more for key dates/graded).

Best Options (Ranked by Price/Convenience)

Top NYC Coin Shops (Verify Hours/Policies)

  • Stack's Bowers (470 Park Ave) — high-end, auction house.
  • New York Gold & Silver (45 W 47th St) — bullion focus.
  • 47th Street Jewelry District (5th–6th Ave) — dozens of dealers; walk & negotiate.
  • Coin Gallery of NYC (30 W 47th St).
  • Liberty Coin Service (online + NYC shows).

Prep Steps

  1. Check **spot price** (Kitco, APMEX).
  2. Verify **condition** (BU, proof, milk spots, scratches).
  3. Keep **original capsule/box/COA** if proof/burnished.
  4. Get **2–3 quotes** before selling.
  5. **ID required** (FinCEN >$600 cash; 1099-B for >$1,000 sales to dealers).

Best overall: Online dealer (lock price, ship insured). **Fastest cash:** Reputable 47th St shop.

United Kingdom
United Kingdom
Wanderlust World
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Australia
  • Canada
  • Caribbean
  • Central America
  • Europe
  • Ireland
  • Mexico
  • New Zealand
  • North America
  • Other Destinations
  • South America
  • South Pacific
  • United Kingdom
  • United States
    • Wanderlust World
    Copyright Wanderlust World © https://www.ynyoo.com
    VenueProsConsTypical Payout
    Online Bullion Dealers (APMEX, JM Bullion, SD Bullion, Bold, Money Metals)Highest bids, lock-in price online, free shipping/insurance, fast ACH/wireMust ship; wait for receipt/verification (1–3 days)Spot + $1.50–$2.50
    Local Coin Shops (LGS)Instant cash, inspect in person, relationship buildingLower bids (spot – $1 to spot + $1), hours limitedSpot – $1 to Spot + $1
    Precious Metals Refineries (Mid-States, Pease & Curren, Manhattan Gold & Silver)Melt & assay — pay on pure content; good for damaged/bulkMinimums (often 10+ oz), 2–5 day settlementSpot – $0.50 to Spot + $1 (melt value)
    Pawn ShopsImmediate cash, no shippingLowest (spot – $3 to –$5), high pressureSpot – $3 to –$5
    eBay / P2P (FB Marketplace, Reddit r/Pmsforsale)Potential retail price (spot + $5–$10)Fees (13% eBay), shipping risk, scams, timeSpot + $3–$8 (net ~Spot + $1–$3)