Some of the most common reports of Smith's ghost include:
* Seeing him sitting in a rocking chair in the hotel's lobby.
* Hearing his footsteps in the hallways.
* Seeing his reflection in the mirrors in the hotel's ballrooms.
* Hearing his voice calling out from the room he used to occupy.
There have also been reports of guests seeing a young girl in a white dress wandering the halls of the hotel. It is believed that this is the ghost of Smith's daughter, who died at a young age.
The Casa Monica Hotel is one of the most popular tourist attractions in Saint Augustine, and many people visit it specifically in the hopes of catching a glimpse of one of its resident ghosts.