Can You Be Evicted for a Cat in New York State? Generally No
NY Pet Protections Are Strong
- State law: Landlord cannot evict solely for having a pet unless it causes damage or threatens health/safety.
- Lease "no-pet" clauses: Unenforceable if you had the pet before signing OR got written permission.
- Fair Housing Act (federal): Requires reasonable accommodation for disability-related animals (ESA, service animals)—even in no-pet buildings.
If Threatened
- Document everything (pet history, communications).
- Contact a tenant lawyer or NYS Homes & Community Renewal.
- NYC has extra protections (Pet Law: 3-month open notoriety = waiver).
Cats are rarely grounds for legal eviction in NY.