- USS Cyclops: A U.S. Navy cargo ship that disappeared in March 1918 while en route to Baltimore from Barbados, carrying 309 passengers and crew.
- USS Proteus: A U.S. Navy tanker that disappeared in November 1941 while en route from St. Thomas to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, with a crew of 83.
- Star Tiger and Star Ariel: Two British South American Airways passenger planes that disappeared in January and December 1948, respectively, while flying from Bermuda to Jamaica and Bermuda to the Bahamas.
- Flight 19: A group of five U.S. Navy training aircraft that disappeared in December 1945 during a routine flight from Florida to the Bahamas.
- Elizabeth and Jane: A pair of cargo ships that disappeared in January 1947 while en route from Charleston, South Carolina to Portugal.
- S.S. Marine Sulphur Queen: A tanker that vanished in February 1963 with 39 crew members on board while sailing from Texas to Virginia.
- Conch Eagle: An American cargo plane that disappeared in January 1972 while flying from Cozumel, Mexico to Belize.
- Connemara IV: A yacht that vanished in October 1975 with four people on board while sailing from Tortola to Puerto Rico.
- El Faro: A U.S.-flagged cargo ship that disappeared in October 2015 with 33 crew members on board, while en route from Jacksonville, Florida to San Juan, Puerto Rico.