Ellis Island sits in Upper New York Bay. Legally, it's part of New Jersey (Supreme Court, 1998: NJ owns 24.5 acres of the 27.5-acre island; NY retains the original 3.3-acre natural island).
But the dispute dates to 1834—a compact gave NY the islands, NJ the underwater land. Landfill expanded the island; NJ sued. The Court split it: original footprint = NY; fill = NJ.
Practically: National Park Service manages it as a federal site. Visitors arrive via NY (Battery Park) or NJ (Liberty State Park). Two states, one icon.