First: Mackinac Island State Park, Michigan (1895).
Second: (Debated—some cite Niagara Falls State Park's 1885 establishment as first, but it was a state reservation initially; formal state park system came later.)
Niagara Falls State Park – Established 1885 as a state reservation; oldest in New York, third nationally.
It's the oldest state park in New York and a National Heritage Area—but not the first in the U.S.