Auto Recovery (Subrogation) in California: How It Works
In California, auto recovery (subrogation) allows insurance companies to reclaim costs paid to their policyholders from at-fault parties. Here's how it operates under California's unique legal framework.
California's Comparative Negligence Rule
California follows pure comparative negligence (Li v. Yellow Cab, 1975). You can recover damages even if 99% at fault—but recovery is reduced by your fault percentage. This applies to subrogation: if your insurer pays your claim, they can only recover the percentage attributable to the other party.
Subrogation Process
- Insurer Pays: Your collision/comprehensive/medpay covers your damages (minus deductible)
- Investigation: Insurer determines fault (police report, evidence, statements)
- Demand: Insurer seeks reimbursement from at-fault party's insurer (or party directly if uninsured)
- Negotiation/Litigation: Inter-company arbitration (common) or lawsuit
- Recovery: If successful, insurer reimburses your deductible proportionally
Key California Scenarios
- Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM): Your insurer pays, then subrogates against at-fault driver personally. California Insurance Code §11580.2 governs.
- Property Damage Only: Often resolved via inter-company arbitration (faster, cheaper)
- Injury Claims: More complex; may involve lien resolution, medical provider subrogation (Medi-Cal, ERISA, private health)
- Made Whole Doctrine: California rejects this—insurer can subrogate even if you're not fully compensated (except MedPay)
Your Rights and Obligations
- Cooperation Clause: Your policy requires assisting insurer's subrogation (statements, docs, testimony)
- No Prejudice: Don't settle with at-fault party without insurer's consent (waives subrogation rights)
- Deductible Recovery: Ask insurer to include your deductible in demand; they'll reimburse pro rata
- Statute of Limitations: 3 years for property (CCP §338), 2 years for injury (CCP §335.1)
Practical Advice
Report accidents promptly. Document everything. Don't admit fault. If other party's insurer contacts you, refer them to yours. Check your policy's subrogation language. Consider a lawyer for injury claims with significant damages.