No carrier flies nonstop; all routes require 1–2 stops. Best-value options (subject to season/sales):
SYD/MEL → Santiago (SCL) → Caribbean (Cancún, Punta Cana, Santo Domingo). Strong South America network.
SYD → Port of Spain (POS) nonstop (787); connects to Barbados, Jamaica, Guyana, etc. Only airline with Australia–Caribbean nonstop leg.
SYD/MEL → Mexico City (MEX) → Cancún, Mérida, Havana. Good Mexico/Caribbean coverage.
SYD/MEL → Panama City (PTY) → 15+ Caribbean destinations. Efficient hub.
SYD → SFO/LAX/HOU → Caribbean (many Star Alliance connections).
SYD/MEL → YVR/YYZ → Caribbean (Star Alliance).
SYD/MEL/BNE → Gold Coast (OOL) → connect Caribbean Airlines (POS) or other.
SYD → HNL → Caribbean (limited: Cancún, Puerto Vallarta).
Fares typically AUD 1,800–3,500 return in economy.