The Caribbean Sea is definitively part of the Atlantic Ocean system. It's classified as a marginal sea—a partially enclosed sea adjacent to an ocean basin, connected by straits.
Boundaries: North—Greater Antilles (Cuba, Hispaniola, Jamaica, Puerto Rico); East—Lesser Antilles arc; South—South America (Venezuela, Colombia, Panama); West—Central America (Mexico, Belize, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica)
Connections: Yucatán Channel (to Gulf of Mexico), Windward/Mona/Passage passages (to Atlantic), Straits of Florida (to Atlantic/Gulf)
Caribbean Surface Water enters via North Equatorial Current, circulates as Caribbean Current, exits through Yucatán Channel as Yucatán Current → Loop Current → Florida Current → Gulf Stream. This conveyor moves heat, salt, larvae, and pollutants between basins.
Unlike the Mediterranean (connected only by narrow Gibraltar), the Caribbean has wide, deep connections to the Atlantic/Gulf, making its circulation, ecology, and climate dynamics more open-ocean-like. Yet its semi-enclosure creates distinct features: Caribbean Low-Level Jet, warm pool, hurricane genesis region.
The Caribbean isn't just "in" the Atlantic—it's a dynamically distinct but integrally connected subsystem of the Atlantic basin.