Counterintuitively, the Great Lakes are warmer on average than the Pacific Ocean. Here's why the numbers flip expectations.
The Pacific's average includes vast abyssal volumes at 1-3°C. Surface temperatures vary wildly: equatorial warm pool (28-30°C), eastern boundary currents (California Current: 10-15°C), subpolar gyre (4-8°C). Volume-weighted, the cold deep ocean dominates.
Relatively shallow (max 406m in Superior), seasonally mixed, no permanent deep cold reservoir. Summer surface temps reach 20-25°C in southern lakes. Winter inverse stratification keeps bottom water at ~4°C (density maximum). Annual average integrates warm summers.
For swimmers, sailors, ecosystems—surface temperature is what counts:
Great Lakes warming faster than oceans: +1-2°C surface since 1995, declining ice cover (22% average vs. 50% historically), longer stratification. Pacific warming is slower but deeper, driving deoxygenation and acidification.
Volume-average: Great Lakes win. Surface experience: it depends on where and when. Both are warming.