New England Colonists' Views of the Dominion of New England (1686-1689)
Imposed Centralization
The Dominion of New England (1686-1689) merged Massachusetts, Plymouth, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, later New York and New Jerseys — under royal governor Sir Edmund Andros. It abolished colonial charters, assemblies, and local laws.
Colonist Reactions
Opposition & Resistance (Dominant)
- Loss of self-government: Elected assemblies replaced by appointed council. "No taxation without representation" precursor.
- Religious threat: Andros enforced Anglican worship (Book of Common Prayer) in Puritan meetinghouses. Old South Church seized for Anglican services.
- Land title insecurity: Quitrent system challenged existing deeds. "Ancient rights" ignored.
- Trade restrictions: Navigation Acts enforced strictly; smuggling prosecuted.
- Military imposition: Redcoats quartered in Boston; militia disbanded.
Boston Revolt (April 18, 1689)
News of Glorious Revolution (William/Mary) reached Boston. Militia and citizens arrested Andros, Dudley, Randolph. Reinstated pre-Dominion governments. Bloodless — model for colonial resistance.
Nuanced Perspectives
- Merchants (some): Welcomed standardized trade, imperial protection.
- Anglicans/Quakers: Relieved persecution by Puritan establishments.
- Maine/N.H. frontier: Appreciated royal defense vs. Wabanaki raids.
Aftermath
Massachusetts got new royal charter (1691) — property suffrage, royal governor, but elected assembly. Plymouth absorbed. Connecticut & Rhode Island restored charters. Self-government restored, but under Crown oversight.
Legacy
Dominion became cautionary tale: colonial rights fragile, resistance effective, unity possible. Precedent for 1760s-70s resistance.