Florida is larger. The original answer had it backward.
| Metric | Florida | New York |
|---|---|---|
| Total Area | 170,312 km² (65,758 sq mi) | 141,297 km² (54,555 sq mi) |
| Land Area | 139,670 km² (53,927 sq mi) | 122,283 km² (47,214 sq mi) |
| Water Area | 30,642 km² (11,831 sq mi) — 18% | 19,014 km² (7,341 sq mi) — 13% |
| Rank (50 states) | 22nd | 27th |
Florida: 500 mi N-S, 360 mi E-W. New York: 330 mi E-W, 310 mi N-S. Florida's "panhandle + peninsula" geometry packs more area.
Bottom line: Florida > New York in area. New York > Florida in GDP ($2.1T vs $1.4T) and cultural footprint. Different metrics, different winners.