The New York Times suggests several places to stay, from the budget-friendly Harborside Resort Motel to pricier options like 1708 House, Gurney's Inn Resort and Seatuck Cove House. It also mentions the Inn at Quogue and Southampton Inn as mid-priced accommodations.
As of August, 2010, prices for the higher-end accommodations started at fifty-eight dollars per night at the Harborside Resort Motel and went up to $1,730 a night for a cottage at Gurney's Inn Resort.
Gurney's and Harborside Resort Motel are in Montauk and both are within walking distance to beaches. 1708 House and Southampton Inn in Southampton have quick access to shops and restaurants. Seatuck Cove House in Eastport is on the shoreline, while the Inn at Quogue in Quogue is further inland.