Troyer's prides itself on offering gourmet twists on traditional Amish dishes. The restaurant is most famous for its baked goods, which include a number of fruit pies, cookies and breads. The restaurant has breakfast and dinner menus that boast a range of comfort foods from prime rib and roasted chicken to grilled fish and pork chops. A buffet lunch and dinner is also offered, every day except Sunday. A banquet room is available for private parties and business meetings.
Troyer's Dutch Heritage
3713 Bahia Vista Street
Sarasota, FL 34232
941-955-8007
troyersdutchheritage.com
The philosophy at Yoder's is to create authentic Amish cooking by making everything from scratch. The restaurant's pot roast and fried chicken are its flagship dishes, with the chicken cooked in a high-pressure fryer to keep it juicy and succulent. But Yoder's is best known for its range of pies, with the most popular being the peanut butter cream pie. In 2010, Adam Richman, host of the Travel Channel's "Man Vs. Food," said that Yoder's offers the "best pies in Florida."
Yoder's Restaurant
3434 Bahia Vista Street
Sarasota, FL 34239
941-955-7771
yodersrestaurant.com
Miller's prides itself on making every one of its dishes from scratch. The restaurant offers extensive breakfast, lunch, dinner and dessert menus with fare to fit any taste. Diners can choose from traditional sandwiches and burgers, honey-glazed ham, fried chicken and a number of seafood selections, among many other dishes. Miller's also offers a breakfast buffet and daily lunch and dinner specials.
Miller's Dutch Kitchen
3401 14th Street West
Bradenton, FL 34205
941-746-8253
millersdutchkitchen.com
Located about 40 miles from both Tampa and Sarasota, the Amish Creamery Company in Madeira Beach is a beachfront ice cream shop, bakery and deli. Customers are drawn in by the allure of many flavors of fresh ice cream and often stay to browse the selection of jams and other preserves, meats and cheeses. The store also offers Amish candies and dry goods, including noodles.
Amish Creamery Company
200 150th Ave.
Madeira Beach, FL 33708
727-397-8222
amishcreamery.com