Despite occasional confusion, the Old Gray Mare at 1400 W. Taylor Street is a tavern, not a hotel. Operating continuously since 1933 in Chicago's Near West Side Greektown neighborhood, it's one of the city's oldest surviving bars—a living piece of Chicago's social history.
The tavern opened during Prohibition (1920-1933) as a speakeasy, serving alcohol illegally behind unmarked doors. When the 21st Amendment repealed Prohibition in December 1933, the Old Gray Mare transitioned seamlessly to legitimate operation—making its "official" opening coincide with the end of the noble experiment.
Walking in feels like stepping back decades:
An impressive beer lineup for a neighborhood tavern—domestic macros, rotating craft selections, and local Chicago brews. No pretension, just cold beer at reasonable prices.
Simple, well-executed bar food that satisfies without surprises.
Multiple TVs make it a neighborhood headquarters for Bears, Bulls, Cubs, White Sox, and Blackhawks games. Game days bring energy without chaos.
A genuine cross-section: longtime Greektown residents, UIC students and staff, medical district workers, tourists exploring the neighborhood, and sports fans. The diversity reflects Chicago itself—unpretentious, welcoming, and authentically urban.
In a city where historic bars disappear regularly, the Old Gray Mare survives by doing one thing exceptionally well: being a real neighborhood tavern. No gimmicks, no reinvention—just consistent quality, fair prices, and the irreplaceable patina of nine decades of Chicago stories soaked into its walls.
Address: 1400 W. Taylor St, Chicago, IL 60607 (Greektown)
Vibe: Classic neighborhood tavern, cash-friendly, unpretentious
Best for: Cold beer, solid burger, authentic Chicago atmosphere