While I cannot retrieve real-time astronomical data for specific past dates, determining the exact sunset time for New York City on March 19, 2011 is entirely possible with the right tools.
Sunset times vary daily based on a location's latitude, longitude, and the Earth's orbital position. For New York City (approximately 40.7° N, 74.0° W), mid-March sunsets typically occur between 6:55 PM and 7:10 PM Eastern Daylight Time, as the vernal equinox approaches.
For the most precise answer, I recommend using the NOAA Solar Calculator with the specific coordinates and date. These tools account for atmospheric refraction, elevation, and the equation of time to provide accuracy within seconds.