Both are treeless, cold biomes with permafrost (continuous in Arctic, discontinuous in Alpine), but they differ fundamentally:
| Aspect | Arctic Tundra | Alpine Tundra |
|---|---|---|
| Location | High latitudes: N. Alaska, Canada, Greenland, Russia, Scandinavia, Arctic islands (60°–90°N) | High elevations: above treeline on mountains worldwide (Alps, Rockies, Andes, Himalayas, East Africa, New Guinea) |
| Climate | Polar: long, severe winters (-30 to -40°C); short, cool summers (3–12°C). Low precipitation (<250 mm). Continuous permafrost. | Montane: cold winters, cool summers; higher precipitation (orographic). Strong UV, high winds, rapid weather shifts. Discontinuous permafrost. |
| Growing Season | 50–60 days | 60–180 days (varies by latitude/elevation) |
| Soils | Thin, nutrient-poor, waterlogged (permafrost impedes drainage); cryoturbation (frost churning). | Thin, rocky, well-drained; high organic matter in meadows; cryoturbation present. |
| Vegetation | Mosses, lichens (reindeer moss), sedges, grasses, dwarf shrubs (willow, birch), cushion plants. No trees. | Alpine meadows: grasses, sedges, wildflowers (gentian, edelweiss), dwarf shrubs, cushion plants, lichens. Krummholz (stunted trees) at lower edge. |
| Wildlife | Caribou/reindeer, muskox, Arctic fox, lemming, polar bear (coastal), snowy owl, ptarmigan, migratory birds. | Marmot, pika, mountain goat, bighorn sheep, ibex, ptarmigan, golden eagle, snow finch, specialized insects. |
| Human Presence | Indigenous (Inuit, Sámi, Nenets, etc.); research stations; resource extraction (oil, gas, minerals). | Seasonal grazing (transhumance), tourism (skiing, hiking), mining, high-altitude communities (Andes, Himalayas). |
| Climate Change Impact | Rapid warming (2–3× global avg); permafrost thaw, shrub expansion, carbon release, habitat loss. | Upward species migration; summit extinctions; glacier loss; water security threat. |
Key distinction: Arctic tundra is latitudinal (poleward); Alpine tundra is elevational (mountaintop). Similar selective pressures → convergent adaptations (low stature, clonal growth, antifreeze proteins), but different evolutionary histories and species pools.