The Old Gray Mare: Chicago's Historic Greektown Tavern (Since 1933)

The Old Gray Mare is not a hotel — it's a legendary tavern at 1400 W. Taylor Street in Chicago's Greektown (Near West Side).

History

• Opened 1933 (Prohibition repeal) — but operated as speakeasy before
• Name: From folk song "The Old Gray Mare" — or possibly a horse that lived on site
• Survived: Expressway construction (I-90/94), UIC expansion, neighborhood cycles
• Family-owned continuously (current: Karavites family since 1970s)

Atmosphere & Decor

• Dark wood paneling, tin ceiling, dim lighting — classic dive aesthetic
• Back bar: Mirrored, packed with bottles
• Booths & bar stools — worn, comfortable
• TVs for sports (no pretension)

Food & Drink

• Beer: 20+ taps (local craft, domestics, European) — strong rotation
• Food: Burgers (certified Angus), fries, wings, Greek apps (saganaki, hummus), sandwiches
• Late-night kitchen (until 1–2 AM) — rare in area

Crowd

• Locals: UIC students/staff, medical district workers, Greektown residents
• Sports fans: Pre/post United Center (Bulls/Blackhawks), Rate Field (White Sox)
• Industry: Chefs, bartenders post-shift
• Tourists: Greektown diners spilling over

Why It Endures

Authenticity. No concept, no rebrand, no Instagram bait. Just a solid neighborhood bar that's seen 90 years of Chicago history pour through its doors.