The statement "Hawaii is larger than Puerto Rico" is correct when comparing the total land area of the State of Hawaii to the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.
Hawaii's total land area is more than three times larger than Puerto Rico's.
Sometimes people compare only the Big Island of Hawaii (10,432 km²) to Puerto Rico, which are similar in size (Big Island is slightly larger). But as political entities, the entire state of Hawaii is significantly larger.
Both are stunning tropical U.S. territories with unique geographies, but Hawaii wins on sheer land mass.