The dramatic temperature difference stems from three primary geographic factors:
Greenland lies near the Arctic Circle (~66.5°N), receiving low-angle, indirect sunlight, especially in winter. The Caribbean sits between 10°–20°N, where the sun is nearly overhead year-round, delivering intense, direct solar radiation.
Much of Greenland is covered by an ice sheet averaging 2,000+ meters (6,560 ft) elevation. Higher altitude means thinner air, which retains less heat. The Caribbean islands are mostly low-lying, allowing denser air to hold warmth.
Combined, these factors give Greenland a polar climate and the Caribbean a tropical one.