Top Italian Restaurants in Nyack, NY

Nyack's Italian Gems

This Hudson River village packs a surprising punch of authentic Italian dining. Here are five standout spots, each with its own character.

1. Mona Lisa

Since 1982. Family-run, warm atmosphere. Extensive menu: house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, branzino, veal scaloppine. Wine list tops 100 labels, heavily Italian. Great for celebrations.

2. La Fontana

Historic 1870 building. Traditional recipes—tagliatelle Bolognese, osso buco, tiramisu. Lovely garden patio for summer evenings. Consistently praised for service.

3. Sotto Sopra

Cozy, central. Known for its wood-fired pizza oven turning out blistered, thin-crust pies. Pastas (cacio e pepe, lobster ravioli) are handmade daily. Intimate date-night vibe.

4. Villaggio

Modern, in Nyack Plaza. Sleek space, full bar with craft cocktails. Menu bridges classic and contemporary: squid ink pasta, grilled octopus, chicken parm. Popular for group dinners.

5. Il Falco

Fine dining. White-tablecloth elegance, 200+ wine list (strong on Barolo, Brunello). Tasting menus available. Reserve well ahead for weekends.

Quick Tips

• Parking: Municipal lots on Main St. and Burd St. (free evenings/weekends).
• Reservations: Essential Friday/Saturday at all five.
• BYOW: None allow corkage; all have curated wine programs.