Sister Bay, WI has three restaurants specializing in American cuisine. Zoey's Beverages & Eatery offers full lunch and dinner menus featuring steak, sandwiches, wraps, a salad bar and fish, as well as a wine list, and both indoor and outdoor seating. Sister Bay Bowl is a small family-owned supper club with a unique menu every night. Common menus include pork tenderloin, liver or corned beef. The Door County Bakery is a more casual establishment offering fresh bread and lunch options like Black Angus chilli.
JJ's La Puerta is Sister Bay's only Mexican restaurant, though it also offers American options like burgers and sandwiches. The restaurant's decor is casual with traditional Mexican art and other decorations. JJ's opens for dinner from Tuesday through Friday and opens in time for brunch on Saturdays but closes on Sunday and Monday.
In honor of Sister Bay's rich Scandinavian heritage, Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant offers a traditional Swedish menu and decor, right down to live goats grazing on the restaurant's sod roof. The menu lists various Swedish meatball dishes, as well as other Scandinavian specialties like Norwegian salmon. The restaurant also offers burgers and traditional American fare for diners looking for comfort food.
Three restaurants in Sister Bay offer more variety in dining options. Fred & Fuzzy's offers grilled sandwiches and a full bar along with both indoor and outdoor seating on the waterfront. Mission Grille is the village's only restaurant offering gluten-free alternatives. The restaurant also boasts an extensive wine list and a landscaped outdoor patio for a scenic view while dining. Finally, the Inn at Kristofer's operates year-round, though closed on Tuesdays, and adjusts its menu based on the seasonal availability of ingredients.
